It may not come as a surprise to anyone that Lies of P, a video game inspired by the original work by Carlo Collodi, has decisions that involve telling truths or lies, and that these in turn have an impact on the different endings of the story. However, things are much more complex than choosing the one we like best.
Tell the truth or lie in Lies of P It has consequences ranging from rewards in the different secondary missions (or quests), affecting the ending that we can choose, to getting an exclusive legendary weapon called the Golden Lie. I already told you everything about the rest of the legendary weapons, but the process for this one is much more complicated and cannot be covered in a single paragraph.
Golden Lie, a prize for compulsive liars
The weapon Golden Lie It is a spear that exudes yellow magical power. It is unique, since the rest of the Fable’s weapons are blue. It has a C scaling in Motor and C in Technique, 94 physical damage, 84 durability and 12.3 weight.
The summary of how to get it is to lie like a bastard to everyone, always, and raise P’s humanity until the nose growing from the painting starts to glow. When it’s ready, we can get it from the Portrait of the Child, which we find in the Town Hall of the Malum district after the first encounter with the Elder Brother of the Black Rabbit Brotherhood.
P’s humanity is increased in several ways: listening to music from the Vinyls (preferably all of them), solving the Riddle King’s riddles, and more. The quickest way to increase it, though, is to tell lies. To get the Golden Lie weapon, you must lie in ALL dialogues.
And here is the question of the post: what are the lies in the dialogues? In most cases, it is enough to look at the context to know what the lie is, but other times it can be confusing. So below is a list of all the lies you must tell throughout the adventure.
|
Location |
Description |
TRUE |
Lie |
Reward |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Krat hotel door |
After defeating the Parade Master boss. This is a mandatory story step. |
Puppet |
Human |
Move forward. It is mandatory to lie. |
|
Mission Weeping Woman |
Found in the streets of Kras during Act 2, before reaching the bridge where we face Crazy Donkey. You have to find the puppet baby (town hall door) and take it to him. |
It’s a puppet |
He’s a beautiful baby |
Feel Vinyl. |
|
The Atoned |
Next to the Funicular in the a. Act 4 is a mandatory stop. |
Do nothing |
I’m a Stalker (requires the Stalker’s Pledge Emote, obtained by defeating the Survivor in Chapter 3) |
The Atoned’s Outfit. |
|
Alidoro, Cathedral of San Frangelico |
It is found in Act 4 and must be found to access the legendary weapons. |
Hotel Krat |
Venigni Works |
Access to legendary weapons. |
|
Alidoro, Venigni Works |
After finishing Act 4, return to Venigni’s Works (Act 3) and look for it at the entrance. |
Hotel Krat |
Elyision Avenue |
Access to legendary weapons. |
|
Julian the Knight’s Mission |
Found in Act 6, next to the second Stargazer. You must complete his quest. |
Of course, it is something unheard of. |
He left a message saying he loved you |
Wedding Ring and Sad Gesture. |
|
Polendina, Hotel Krat |
Just progress through the story. After defeating the Puppet King. It is related to the previous mission. |
Show her the wedding ring |
There is no puppet like this |
X |
|
Antonia, Hotel Krat |
After defeating the Puppet King. |
There is nothing left |
Of course |
X |
|
Simon Manus, Great Exhibition |
After defeating Champion Victor. |
Hope for healing |
Monsters |
X |
|
Polendina, Hotel KrAT |
This lie is particularly cruel. Right after the previous lie, you have to craft the cure for Antonia with Giangio (next to the tree in the Hotel). Once crafted, talk to Polendina |
I would use the remedy |
I would not use the remedy |
X |
|
Eugénie for Alidoro, mission |
Find Alidoro next to the first shortcut in Act 8. Talk to Eugénie, complete her assignment, and return. |
He got angry. He said that the gloves were garbage. |
I was happy |
X |
|
King of Riddles, Side Quest |
After solving four puzzles and opening the rooms, you have to return to the last cabin where you spoke to the King. |
Yeah |
No |
Trinitarian Key of the Chosen One (regardless of the answer) |
|
Belle’s Mission, Hotel Krat |
After finding her at The Exhibition, progress through the story and talk to her from time to time. After sending us to find her lover and finding him at Krat Station, Act 9. |
He has become a monster |
He died in combat against a puppet |
Why Vinyl |
|
Venigni on Frenzy |
During Act 10, you have to talk to Vergini. |
Geppetto caused the Puppet Frenzy |
I haven’t heard it |
X |
|
Eugénie and the fate of Alidoro |
Alidoro must be found in Act 10 and killed, then spoken to Eugénie again. |
The fake Alidoro killed the real one |
I think he was just a skilled stalker. |
Lying: Far east princess vinyl Truth: Vinyl Proposal, Flower, Wolf Part 1 |
|
Arlecchino, Trinitarian Sanctuary of the Chosen One |
It is found in Act 11 |
Puppet |
Human |
Quartz and Alchemist’s Cloak |
|
Sophia, Island of the Alchemists |
Mandatory step after defeating Laxasia the Whole. |
Let her live |
Let her rest in peace |
Letter from Geppetto’s workshop and Shadow Flower Vinyl |
|
Geppetto, Island of the Alchemists |
Act 11. |
No |
Yeah |
X |
|
Simon Manus, final |
The peculiarity of this answer is that it will be true if we have always told the truth and a lie if we have always lied… or at least most of the time in both cases. |
I have freed her from Arche Abbey |
I have freed her from Arche Abbey |
X |
Assuming you did all the steps correctly, then you should return to the Krat Hotel after the credits and not access NG+. If you do the latter, you will have ruined all the work in the game. The nose on the painting should be glowing gold. Simply interact with it and you’re good to go. To be completely honest, the weapon’s stats don’t make up for all the work it takes to get it. If you’re a gun collector, though, this is the rarest one you’re going to get.
